| Year |
Name |
School |
| 1980 |
Joni Griffith |
Iowa State University |
| 1982 |
Laura Bonner |
Howard University |
| 1984 |
Milana Marsenich |
Montana State University |
| 1985 |
Victoria Johnson |
Montana State University |
| 1986 |
Dana Hee |
Canada College |
| 1987 |
Julie Werhnyak |
University of Illinois-Chicago |
| 1988 |
Julie Werhnyak |
University of Illinois-Chicago |
| 1989 |
Kristi Koch |
Indiana University |
| 1990 |
Nancy Ferguson |
Ohlone College |
| 1991 |
Jennifer Srutowski |
Lewis University |
| 1992 |
Linda Buell |
Pepperdine University |
| 1993 |
Anna Kim |
University of California-Berkeley |
| 1994 |
Anna Kim |
University of California-Berkeley |
| 1995 |
Anna Kim |
Kent State University |
| 1996 |
Kelly Thorpe |
University of Central Oklahoma |
| 1997 |
Jennifer Mohammed |
Hofstra University |
| 1998 |
Elizabeth Mohammed |
Hofstra University |
| 1999 |
Elizabeth Mohammed |
Hofstra University |
| 2000 |
Kelly Thorpe |
University of Washington |
| 2001 |
Elizabeth Mohammed |
Hofstra University |
| 2002 |
Darcy Kimmich |
University of Denver |
| 2003 |
Darcy Kimmich |
University of Denver |
| 2004 |
Colleen Schneider |
University of California-Berkeley |
| 2005 |
Andrea Ferkile |
University of Colorado-Colorado Springs |
| 2006 |
Suad Jafarzadeh |
Montgomery Community College |
| 2007 |
Nia Abdallah |
American Sports University |
| 2008 |
Ana Portillo |
Stanford University |
| 2009 |
Emma Wu |
Harvard University |
| 2010 |
Amber Means |
University of Houston |
| 2011 |
Jennifer Daye |
University of Central Oklahoma |
| 2012 |
Nicole Palma |
University of Miami |